• Menu
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

NewHomeSource

  • Learning Center
  • Just For You
    • First Time Home Buyers
    • 55 Plus
    • International Buyers
    • For The Military
    • Single Women
  • Home Types
    • Custom Homes
    • Condos & Townhomes
    • Luxury Homes
    • Tiny Houses
    • Manufactured Homes
  • Resources
    • Home Buying Tools
    • Mortgage Calculator
    • Home Affordability Calculator
    • Trustbuilder Ratings & Reviews
  • Learning Center
  • Just For You
    • First Time Home Buyers
    • 55 Plus
    • International Buyers
    • For The Military
    • Single Women
  • Home Types
    • Custom Homes
    • Condos & Townhomes
    • Luxury Homes
    • Tiny Houses
    • Manufactured Homes
  • Resources
    • Home Buying Tools
    • Mortgage Calculator
    • Home Affordability Calculator
    • Trustbuilder Ratings & Reviews
Home » 55+ » The 10 Best Places to Retire in Indiana

The 10 Best Places to Retire in Indiana

For years, you’ve worked in an office anticipating the day when you could enjoy an unbeatable retirement. Indiana will deliver with its beautiful scenery, all four seasons, and bustling cities with exciting cultures. Retiring in Indiana means making the lifestyle you focused on to get you through long days of work a reality. 

NewHomeSource has compiled the top 10 cities to retire in Indiana. Explore these fantastic cities and browse their 55+ communities to find the perfect place for your perfect new home during this exciting new chapter in your life.

Top 10 Cities to Retire in Indiana

Skip Ahead
1. Peru
2. Logansport
3. Gary
4. Marion
5. Connersville
6. New Castle
7. Anderson
8. Muncie
9. East Chicago
10. Vincennes
Common Questions About Retiring in Indiana

1. Peru

Circus parade in Peru, Indiana

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 17.3%

Median Home Value: $61,200

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 59

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 347

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 4

Peru, Indiana has something for all types of retirees. Nature lovers can stay active and healthy while exploring the Seven Pillars Nature Preserve and the Mississinewa Reservoir and Lake. Peru’s fun culture will appeal to people looking to enjoy fun museums and good restaurants. Its low cost of living and median home price is an added bonus for anyone on a fixed income.

2. Logansport

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 15.9%

Median Home Value: $68,800

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 23

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 534

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 3

Sitting at the intersection of the Eel and Wabash Rivers is the charming community of Logansport. It’s a popular place for retirees who want to live in a peaceful but fun town. In addition to its numerous parks and recreational spots, Logansport also has numerous historical spots and museums for you to explore.

3. Gary

View of Lake Michigan in Gary, Indiana

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 18.4%

Median Home Value: $66,100

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 423

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 2,687

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 31

You can enjoy an affordable lakefront retirement when you make your home in Gary. This lovely community on the shores of Lake Michigan is the perfect setting for active adults who envision spending their days boating and swimming. You’ll also want to set aside time to explore the Indiana Dunes National Park. You don’t have to ride a dune buggy like in Napoleon Dynamite, but you totally could if you wanted.

4. Marion

City view of Marion, Indiana

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 17.9%

Median Home Value: $67,800

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 104

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 871

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 1

Marion is a charming community between Fort Wayne and Indianapolis. Retirees have plenty of things to keep them busy during their golden years when they make their home in Marion. Two things you will want to do is explore the Quilter Hall of Fame and the historical Hostess House. The beautiful Cardinal Greenway gives nature lovers the perfect place to go biking.

5. Connersville

historic bridge in connorsville indiana

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 19.9%

Median Home Value: $71,500

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 16

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 103

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 3

Connersville, IN gives retirees easy access to all the excitement found in Indianapolis and Cincinnati, while still providing them with an affordable and peaceful place to call home. If you want to spend your retirement enjoying the best in the Midwest, you can’t go wrong calling Connersville home. 

6. New Castle

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 18.1%

Median Home Value: $73,300

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 2

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 199

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 5

If you’re hoping to relax and enjoy the great outdoors during your retirement, then New Castle is the perfect town for you. This safe and affordable community offers a comfortable quality of life, while local parks like Summit Lake State Park make it easy for residents of all ages to stay active and healthy. 

7. Anderson

Waterfall in Anderson, Indiana

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 18%

Median Home Value: $72,900

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 247

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 2,100

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 9

If you are dreaming of a tranquil place to live during your retirement, you’ll love Anderson. This affordable Indianapolis suburb has plenty of local museums and parks to keep you entertained and active. Anderson fosters a comfortable and peaceful community that makes it easy for you to kick back and relax. 

8. Muncie

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 13.9%

Median Home Value: $73,500

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 222

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 2,205

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 4

Muncie is a historic Indianapolis suburb that can excite even the most committed couch potato. Museum lovers have the National Model Aviation Museum, the Oakhurst Gardens, the David Owsley Museum of Art, and the Charles W. Brown Planetarium at their fingertips. Morrow’s Meadow allows active adults to enjoy Mother Nature, while local wineries let them take a walk on the wild side. 

9. East Chicago

Chicago community

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 14.1%

Median Home Value: $74,500

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 202

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 1,097

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 46

If you want to call the Windy City home during your retirement, but prefer having a serene community to call home, then you’ll love life in East Chicago, IN. This comfortable and affordable Chicago suburb lets retirees enjoy everything people about Chi-Town, without having to endure the constant noise and commotion of the city. 

10. Vincennes

Boats on the Wabash River in Vincennes, Indiana

Percentage of the Population Over 65: 16.8%

Median Home Value: $77,700

Most Recent Annual Number of Violent Crimes: 20

Most Recent Annual Number of Property Crimes: 797

Number of Hospitals Within One Mile of the City: 2

Vincennes is a thriving urban hub on the banks of the Wabash River. The George Rogers National Park has historical architecture for you to admire and great walking paths where you can get some exercise. If you’re in the mood to spend your retirement exploring local historic sites and beautiful parks, then you’ll love your life in Vincennes.

NewHomeSource pulled data from the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting Services, Medicare’s Hospital Compare and the U.S. Census Bureau. In the event exact crime data was unavailable, estimates were used. Median home price, number of hospitals, 65+ population, and crime rates were entered into an algorithm to calculate a score for each city whose population is at least 10,000.

Common Questions About Retiring in Indiana

Where does Indiana rank for retirees?

Indiana is ranked as the third best state for retirees, thanks to its low cost of living and fun culture.

Is Indiana a tax-friendly state for retirees?

Indiana is a fairly tax-friendly state for retirees. Income from Social Security is exempt from the state income tax, its cost of living is low, and it has low property taxes.

city name state name people over 65 violent crimes property crimes access to doctors median home price
Indianapolis Indiana 12.20% 10,940.00 33,508.00 20 $137,000
Fort Wayne Indiana 14.00% 978.00 7,451.00 10 $115,100
Evansville Indiana 16.10% 725.00 4,926.00 4 $94,200
South Bend Indiana 12.80% 1,362.00 4,318.00 8 $85,200
Carmel Indiana 13.30% 30.00 808.00 20 $333,200
Fishers Indiana 8.90% 51.00 735.00 19 $264,200
Bloomington Indiana 9.50% 490.00 2,448.00 2 $200,700
Hammond Indiana 12.30% 317.00 2,801.00 39 $91,700
Gary Indiana 18.40% 423.00 2,687.00 31 $66,100
Lafayette Indiana 13.20% 355.00 2,398.00 3 $114,800
Muncie Indiana 13.90% 222.00 2,205.00 4 $73,500
Noblesville Indiana 11.30% 32.00 619.00 17 $209,100
Terre Haute Indiana 15.10% 147.00 2,526.00 2 $78,700
Kokomo Indiana 19.00% 397.00 1,498.00 3 $89,100
Greenwood Indiana 14.40% 97.00 1,528.00 18 $155,300
Anderson Indiana 18.00% 247.00 2,100.00 9 $72,900
Elkhart Indiana 13.00% 614.00 1,690.00 7 $95,900
Mishawaka Indiana 15.50% 110.00 2,319.00 7 $102,900
Lawrence Indiana 11.60% 180.00 1,102.00 20 $148,700
Jeffersonville Indiana 14.80% 119.00 1,354.00 8 $136,900
Columbus Indiana 17.40% 68.00 1,442.00 3 $125,200
West Lafayette Indiana 6.90% 47.00 658.00 3 $224,000
Westfield Indiana 10.90% 16.00 338.00 17 $254,800
Portage Indiana 15.40% 74.00 589.00 20 $152,500
New Albany Indiana 16.20% 80.00 1,483.00 7 $122,800
Richmond Indiana 18.50% 14.00 102.00 3 $88,400
Valparaiso Indiana 17.00% 37.00 372.00 15 $185,800
Goshen Indiana 17.60% 47.00 1,045.00 7 $121,100
Michigan City Indiana 15.20% 223.00 1,245.00 7 $89,900
Crown Point Indiana 19.60% 8.00 294.00 18 $194,600
Marion Indiana 17.90% 104.00 871.00 1 $67,800
Hobart Indiana 16.30% 40.00 967.00 21 $142,700
East Chicago Indiana 14.10% 202.00 1,097.00 46 $74,500
Franklin Indiana 15.90% 94.00 516.00 10 $129,200
Greenfield Indiana 18.90% 21.00 306.00 19 $139,000
La Porte Indiana 16.90% 117.00 470.00 7 $99,300
Seymour Indiana 14.20% 45.00 874.00 2 $119,800
Shelbyville Indiana 15.30% 146.00 407.00 7 $102,100
Logansport Indiana 15.90% 23.00 534.00 3 $66,800
Vincennes Indiana 16.80% 20.00 797.00 2 $77,700
New Castle Indiana 18.10% 2.00 199.00 5 $73,300
Huntington Indiana 15.80% 6.00 54.00 7 $81,800
Crawfordsville Indiana 17.70% 68.00 347.00 3 $107,500
Lebanon Indiana 15.90% 74.00 373.00 15 $124,500
Frankfort Indiana 14.10% 11.00 429.00 5 $83,400
New Haven Indiana 16.90% 47.00 327.00 8 $103,400
Jasper Indiana 18.20% 50.00 196.00 2 $155,300
Beech Grove Indiana 15.20% 24.00 286.00 21 $101,600
Warsaw Indiana 13.30% 76.00 519.00 3 $135,200
Bedford Indiana 21.50% 30.00 296.00 2 $94,800
Auburn Indiana 17.10% 11.00 156.00 8 $119,700
Connersville Indiana 19.90% 16.00 103.00 3 $71,500
Washington Indiana 17.20% 36.00 285.00 3 $86,300
Lake Station Indiana 12.20% 31.00 292.00 24 $84,400
Greensburg Indiana 18.20% 35.00 59.00 2 $120,800
Madison Indiana 20.10% 15.00 114.00 2 $133,000
Martinsville Indiana 15.90% 80.00 343.00 8 $98,500
Peru Indiana 17.30% 59.00 347.00 4 $61,200
Greencastle Indiana 16.10% 43.00 243.00 1 $105,700
Wabash Indiana 20.00% 2.00 56.00 2 $82,400
Bluffton Indiana 19.20% 9.00 163.00 5 $100,300
city name state name people over 65 violent crimes property crimes access to doctors median home price

Access to Doctors is calculated by finding the number of hospitals, discounting children’s hospitals and VA hospitals within one mile of the city.

sarah-scott-photo
Sarah Scott

Sarah graduated from Trinity University in 2012 with a degree in International Relations and Political Science. She writes blogs on new homes, decor, communities, and more for NewHomeSource. When she’s not writing, you can find her spending time with her three cats.

Get our FREE guide on how the home construction process works

By downloading our guide, you can also look forward to receiving our New Home 101 short email series. You may opt out of this subscription any time you wish.

Previous Post: «red living room chair, with purple pillow 7 Projects to Spruce Up Your Living Room on a Budget
Next Post: The 10 Best Places to Retire in Virginia in 2021 White colonial home, the Rose Hill Plan by Lennar in the Colonial Heritage community in Norfolk-Newport News VA»

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search new homes

New Home 101

  • The Basics of Newly Built Homes
  • Why Buy a Newly Built Home
  • Shopping for Your New Home
  • Building Your New Home
  • Designing Your Dream Home
  • Buying Your New Home
  • Moving Into Your New Home
  • New Home Glossary

Footer

Quick Links

  • 55+ Communities
  • Condos & Townhomes
  • Custom Home Buyers
  • First-Time Buyers
  • Luxury Homes
  • Manufactured Homes

Related Sites & Resources

  • Learning Center
  • CasasNuevasAqui.com
  • HomLuv.com
  • Real Estate Professionals
  • NewHomeSource App
  • Trust Builder Ratings & Reviews

Helpful Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Builders: List your homes!
  • Unsubscribe
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information

Copyright © 2023 · Builders Digital Experience, LLC. All rights reserved. NewHomeSource.com is a trademark of Builders Digital Experience, LLC and all other marks are either trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners.

Dynamic title for modals

Are you sure?

Please confirm deletion. There is no undo!